Because the beaver isn't just an animal; it's an ecosystem!

Category: Attitudes towards beavers


Yesterday I stumbled across the newly formed Western Beaver Cooperative, brain child of Reese Mercer formerly of Beaver Works and now leading the way with this volunteer based effort. The website is full of good advice and nice graphics that might come in handy. I don’t know the backstory on why one cooperative suddenly ends and another begins, but working with an all volunteer army is a tough gig and sometimes there are human obstacles that cannot be over come.

I especially liked this graphic…

And this awesome collection of webcam captured visits to a beaver pond during the third year of drought, Watch the whole thing because I especially like the field mice and the night jar.

000


The World Wildlife Fund is a glossy high powered nonprofit that saves high profile animals like Pandas and Penguins. In the past couple of years they’ve become interested in beavers, and there was some work they were doing in PEI to help salmon navigate around beaver dams. (!!) I am a traditionalist when it comes to beavers. I generally think that if there was an easier way to prevent beavers building up dam they would have found it by now.

But what do I know?

To trap or not to trap: Dam good options for coexistence

JACKSON, Wyo. — Wyoming Wetlands Society (WWS) and the U.S. Forest Service (USFS) are currently working to support coexistence with beavers as a longer term solution to trapping. This past month, the organizations collaborated on a dam notch exclosure fence on Dog Creek in the Snake River Canyon in an effort to preserve beaver presence and wetland creation while protecting the area’s infrastructure.

Cody Pitz, wildlife biologist and beaver restoration program coordinator with WWS, tells Buckrail the project is intended to reduce beaver conflict by allowing the beavers to remain in the landscape while mitigating for road flooding. He says a dam notch exclosure fence (pictured here) is a more efficient and cost-friendly option to a pond leveler, and maintains water levels by allowing water to freely flow through a fenced notch in the dam.

“This is new to the Bridger-Teton, so we’re figuring out things as we go,” Ashley Egan, Bridger-Teton National Forest wildlife biologist, shares with Buckrail. “This project was a perfect success example. It’s showing the community, our visitors and other folks who do land management in the GYE that there are tools out there for beaver coexistence.”

Pitz says he’s optimistic that more people are coming around to the idea that beavers are a necessary part of the ecosystem. While beavers can have different impacts in an area, he says the dam notch exclosure fence is just one of a number of different approaches that can be considered before live-trapping and relocating the keystone species.

Hmm. Hmm. Hmmm. I guess I could be wrong here but I generally think if I was a beaver and suddenly I couldn’t fix the dam that was protecting my house anymore I would just build another one. Wouldn’t you? I mean the materials are right there and the labor is free…

“I’m optimistic that we can get more onboard with coexisting with beavers,” Pitz tells Buckrail. “As more and more people understand the benefits of beavers, we can get there.”

Egan echoes this sentiment with the USFS. According to her, finding a balance between appreciating the benefits of beavers to riparian and wetland ecologies and maintaining infrastructure lies in utilizing beaver engineering skills as a management tool. The BTNF will re-evaluate the dam notch exclusion fence’s success in the springtime, and are committed to investing in continued alternative solutions.

“We’re not just going to be giving up,” Egan says. “We want to showcase that this can work. We don’t need to trap beaver out of the landscape just because there’s a road there. WWS has contributed a ton of expertise, and we’re hoping that there’s more coming down the pipe.”

Notch fence? What do I know? Maybe it’s about the audience. Maybe he figures that the odds of a NOTCH FENCE working are slightly higher than the odds of talking any rancher in Wyoming to coexist with beaver in the first place.  If that’s the case, then good look to you.

 


Long ago, before the supreme court had decided rights were impermanent and could be snatched away at a moments notice, there was a general delicacy in how democrats protected the right to an abortion. They thought it was kind of important and kind of icky at the same time, and struck the hearty compromise of saying it was important to keep the procedure “Safe Legal and Rare.”

(That kind of thing wouldn’t hold its own weight anymore because women are pretty much done acting ashamed of their own bodily autonomy but it does happen to apply to my feelings about trapping beavers so I thought we’d discuss it today.)

In general I am sure you guessed that I’m of the mind that it is a better idea to cooperate with beavers than to trap them. I think trapping is icky, it’s cruel, and it’s a waste of a valuable resource that could have produced many benefits to the community. But even I begrudgingly admit that there are some situations and some places where it is sometimes necessary. Far Far Far less than it actually happens, mind you, but in some levees or sewer lines or crop lands maybe beavers can’t be saved. When that happens there should be rules about how the animal is treated so it doesn’t suffer and a record of the event so we can count how rare it is and everybody should realize that it was an expensive solution that costs the community for years to come.

Safe Legal & Rare.

In no way should it be glorified or sanctified or protected from scrutiny. Trappers are not heroes and they should not get a pass. But I continue to think of them as a foot soldier in a war whose commanders we need to fight more fiercely. They are a distraction from the real fight, I had a conversation yesterday with someone who was very upset about Beaverland because they felt it elevated and sanctified beaver trapping. Which I can understand . They weren’t wild about the author being the keynote speaker at the conference and they wisely argued that Ben’s book made people think in new ways about beavers and for the most part Leila’s book made people feel like it was okay not to.

I have noticed that there is a kind of attitude which implies that serious beaver advocates don’t fight with trappers and only crazy PETA people object because smart savvy people know that its necessary. I’ve heard this argument from some surprising people and places and from people that we think of as beaver heroes. I’ve seen it become a kind of litmus test where people try to find out if you are a serious or unserious beaver advocate by finding out how you feel about trapping.

Because there are so many “trapping chapters” in Beaverland, the author gets credited as producing a more serious and defensable book than Eager where Ben made them seem so cool. NPR and the NYT add weight to the argument. It’s almost like the world sighed with relief when her book emerged because Eager made them feel like they were doing something wrong before and she said, no go ahead. Keep right on trapping them.

Just so you know, I am serious as a heart attack. I try not to get distracted by trappers themselves either to vilify or glorify them. For the most part I believe that they are irrelevant. I am more focused on the failed SOLUTION trapping offers and the people that pay them to do it.

Because when it comes to beavers, I am pretty sure trapping needs to be SAFE, LEGAL & RARE.

 


The High Desert Museum in Oregon is one of the most respected museums in the world. It was my father’s favorite and has featured some truly breathtaking beaver exhibits including the interactive grapahic featured in the margin of this page. Once they even asked to use our ecosystem poster in a beaver exhibit.

And now they have this:

Baby beaver from John Day finds home at High Desert Museum

The High Desert Museum recently welcomed a new animal who happens to be an expert engineer, a keystone ecosystem species and the largest rodent in North America.

A baby beaver, called a kit, arrived at the Museum in May. Found in John Day alone in a parking lot, people had searched the area for her family but failed. The kit was then placed into the care of Museum wildlife staff by the Oregon Department of Fish and Wildlife.

Veterinarians estimated at the time that the animal was only a few weeks old. The beaver was very weak and dehydrated, weighing just 1.4 pounds. Wildlife staff spent the next several months working to formulate an appropriate diet and nurse the kit back to health.

“The Museum’s wildlife team was tireless in researching appropriate diet options and providing around-the-clock care,” says Museum Executive Director Dana Whitelaw, Ph.D. “Their dedication to providing the best care is exceptional.”

It took most of the summer for the beaver’s condition to improve, but the baby slowly began to gain weight and strength.

Six months later, the beaver is healthy and growing, now at almost 17 pounds. Staff have built a behind-the-scenes space to meet a beaver’s needs, complete with a pool for swimming. The kit eats a species-appropriate diet of native riparian browse such as willow, aspen and cottonwood, supplemented with vegetables and formulated zoological diets to ensure proper nutrition.

The plan is that when ready, the beaver will become an ambassador for her species by appearing in talks at the Museum that educate visitors about the High Desert landscape.

Just to be clear I HATE when orphans are raised in captivity to be ambassadors but of all the places to be kept on display this is probably the creme of the crop. And who knows, maybe he’ll get a companion one day.

The beaver is doing well and learning behaviors that assist with her care,” says Curator of Wildlife Jon Nelson. “She is learning target training, how to sit on a scale to be weighed and to present her feet for voluntary inspections and nail trims. She also enjoys time playing in the Museum’s stream after hours.”

The beaver is believed to be female. It’s challenging to conclusively identify male or female beavers.

The opportunity to name the beaver was auctioned at the 2023 High Desert Rendezvous. The winning bidder has yet to select a name, which must be appropriate for the Museum and connected to the High Desert.

An estimated 60 million to 400 million beavers once lived in North America, creating wetlands and ponds. The dams built by these “ecosystem engineers” slow streamflow, raise the water table and reduce downstream flooding and erosion. Beavers also help birds, fish and other wildlife and native plants to thrive by creating habitat.

Beaver populations dropped dramatically in the last two centuries with demand for beaver pelts for clothing, most notably hats, in the mid-19th century. Their dam-building activities also at times prompt people to consider them a pest on their properties.

Today in the West, restoration of the beaver is underway and humans in some areas are mimicking its dam-building behavior in order to restore healthy High Desert riparian areas.

“The history of beavers in the High Desert is a profound one,” Whitelaw says. “We hope to be able to share the new beaver at the Museum with visitors soon to help tell the meaningful stories about the role these animals have to play in healthy ecosystems.”

The Museum cares for more than 120 animals, from otters to raptors. Many of the animals are nonreleasable, either due to injuries or because they became too familiar with humans. At the Museum, they serve as ambassadors that educate visitors about the conservation of High Desert species and landscapes.

I’m sure she’ll be called rattle snake or Justin soon. But remember, two years ago the museum dd the best exhibit ever for beavers and the difference they make so take heart little one, at least your among friends.


Last night at the conference was the lovely prime rib dinner and a keynote talk by Leila Philips. I’m told that the Martinez beavers were mentioned by both Mike and Brock and I’m sure many exciting things happened that we’ll hear about eventually. In the meantime there was a great article about Human Beaver Coexistence from Maryland that I know you want to see.

A beaver champion in Virginia and the need for more like her

Which brings me to Alison Zak, a Northern Virginia resident who operates, all by herself, the Human-Beaver Coexistence Fund, worthy of your interest and support. We need more like her throughout the 64,000-square-mile Chesapeake watershed facilitating beavers, the most charismatic link to water quality I know of.

“You can’t conserve wildlife without understanding and working with the people who will interact with that wildlife,” Zak said.

As she’s talking, we’re knee deep in the chilly swamp headwaters of Maryland’s Magothy River, a Bay tributary where she showed locals how to chew-proof an assortment of streamside maples, oaks and gums they didn’t want taken down by beavers.

An anthropologist by training, Zak, a Florida native, was living not so long ago on Sulawesi Island in Indonesia, studying seven endangered species of macaque monkeys. Having decided against years’ more research for a Ph.D., she migrated to environmental education work in Virginia’s Fauquier County.

There, she encountered wild beavers for the first time and became fascinated — or, she admits, “obsessed” with the animal. Landowners began to seek her advice on their beaver interactions.

“Most didn’t know much about them. They just knew this animal had shown up and [was] changing their property … flooding, chewing … that’s what beavers do.”

Alison is the coordinator of the beaver education group I meet with every month. She also just published a book on animal Yoga which fully proves there are all kinds of beaver supporters in the world.

In 2021, she founded the Human-Beaver effort, working on coexistence projects from West Virginia to the Magothy — “anywhere I can reasonably drive.”

She is close to becoming a bona fide “beaver professional,” a certification offered by the Beaver Institute in Southampton, MA. Tuition is $2,500 and requires roughly 60 hours of online coursework, plus completion of four field projects.

These mostly work on the flooding issues that result when beavers impound water, which they do for their own safety, avoiding predators in the depths of their pond. In more than 90% of cases, Zak said, there are viable nonlethal solutions.

Easily maintained low-tech “flow devices,” for instance, can keep water deep enough for the beavers while preventing flooding. Where beavers block road culverts, a common issue, the solution is either flow devices or “beaver dam analogs” — human-made dams that encourage the rodents to relocate their own dams away from the culvert.

Engaging landowners and highway departments (for culverts) depends a lot on education, Zak said. “Because beavers are just now slowly rebounding after being gone so long [trapped out of the Chesapeake by mid-1700s], there’s a sort of ecological amnesia … A true beaver wetland to most of us looks like chaos. Single-channel streams spreading out to multiple channels, dead and dying trees, unruly vegetation.”

Her work usually begins with relationship building, understanding the landowners’ values and points of view. As for trappers, “I don’t vilify them,” she said. “They know a lot about beavers.”

Well she’s young and idealistic. She should be. She has years before she turns into a gnarled and battle scarred old advocate like me, right?

“We’re on the right trajectory. Beaver consciousness is growing. There are several good books out there,” she said, referring to Ben Goldfarb’s Eager — the Surprising Secret Life of Beavers and Why They Matter (2018) and Leila Philip’s more recent Beaverland — How One Weird Rodent Made America (2022).

She says real promise lies in working with trappers, who are frequently a landowner’s go-to when beavers arrive. “How can we make it lucrative for them to offer nonlethal solutions?”

Promise also lies with highway departments who must deal (often harshly) with beavers blocking highway culverts. In both instances, coexistence is a cheaper solution than constantly trapping or tearing out dams every year.

Solutions also need to be more regional, she said, because as beaver populations grow, new generations move upstream or to other streams.

Where we wade in the upper Magothy exemplifies the need for a more comprehensive approach. The beaver dam there gets torn down every spring by fisheries biologists, worried that threatened yellow perch can’t migrate farther upstream to spawn.

A simple solution, Zak thinks, would be to induce the beavers to dam outside a concrete culvert there, allowing easier dam bypass for the perch.

The Beaver Institute has trained more than 80 people nationwide to do what Zak does and is looking for more recruits.

So how about this as a new Bay restoration goal: at least one trained beaver problem-solver in every government environmental and transportation agency, as well as every environmental nonprofit?

I would like 5 of you in

DONATE

TREE PROTECTION

BAY AREA PODCAST

Our story told around the county

Beaver Interactive: Click to view

LASSIE INVENTS BDA

URBAN BEAVERS

LASSIE AND BEAVERS

Ten Years

The Beaver Cheat Sheet

Restoration

RANGER RICK

Ranger rick

The meeting that started it all

Past Reports

November 2024
M T W T F S S
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
252627282930  

Story By Year

close

Share the beaver gospel!