Because the beaver isn't just an animal; it's an ecosystem!

“Twice Extinct” – it’s just like ‘twice blessed’, only deader.


6825195-large[1]English beavers face wipe-out for the second time at the hands of humans

Wildlife ‘control’ could mean the beaver is lost from the English landscape before it gets re-established. Beaver expert Derek Gow mourns its likely passing.

 As the beaver families on the River Otter snuggle together today in their cosy nests of shredded willow they cannot conceive that they are about to participate in a remarkable historic event.

At the beginning of the 21st century, in the time if the “greenest Government ever” their removal at the hand of Defra’s trappers will ensure that they become the first ever native English mammal to have been exterminated by humans twice.

 I should have known better to be hopeful about the broadly-attended public meeting in Devon. I should have realized that the fact that DEFRA didn’t bother to be there spoke volumes. This article does an amazing job of targeting their asymmetrical illogic point by point and concludes that in this instance facts and public opinion and economics don’t matter.

10636153_724205444281516_2505342535526560248_n

Children and senior citizens, students and business men stood up at the end of the presentations to state their wish to see the beavers remain. Letters of support from farmers who could not attend were read out by councillors.

 Many people cited their appeal as a tourist attraction, others pointed out the hypocrisy of our national position whereby we lecture others on the conservation of threatened species such as tigers or elephants while making no effort to restore our own depleted wildlife. At the end of the evening a show of hands was unanimous in its support for the retention of the beavers on the River Otter.

 Defra did not attend the event. On the same day their field staff were collecting from Scotland the traps they require to remove the Devon beavers. To date despite considerable media attention, representations to senior civil servants and ministers, national petitions which have attracted over 30,000 signatures and the clear will of the local community they have made no effort to attain or consider a balanced approach on this issue.

 Did you catch that?  While the citizens of Devon were bravely assembled to talk about beaver benefits and problem-solving, bright-eyed children and craggy old farmers and gray haired dears all coming together to talk about making Devon a better place, DEFRA in their infinite badger-killing wisdom was getting ready the beaver traps. The deceptions of a certain Grinch spring to mind.

And when Cindy Loo Hoo went to bed with her cup.
He went to the chimney and stuffed the tree up.

This makes even a battle-scared rodeo clown like me feel sad and hopeless. It’s hard to believe that Devon could do everything right, the  meeting, the science, the overseeing trust, the media, the farmers, the school children, the shop owners, and it doesn’t matter at all because DEFRA will do whatever the heck it wants to do. No matter what.

Did mention this is depressing?

Have any Question or Comment?

5 comments on ““Twice Extinct” – it’s just like ‘twice blessed’, only deader.

This is utterly appalling. It makes me proud of our Scottish Government who listened to the people and the scientists, and agreed to a sensible compromise – to tolerate and monitor the beavers in the Tay, following a programme of selective trapping and re-releasing to ensure that they are the right species and healthy. (They are – and they are still here and breeding well for anyone who is unfamiliar with the story).

If this is the end of the story in England, then I am beyond words. I am so disappointed for the beavers who will not flourish in zoos – if they even get that far, for the people of Devon who so wanted them to be left, and for all the beneficiaries of the environmental improvements that these wonderful animals can bring.

Polly Pearshouse

This is so, so sad. I knew I didn’t have much time for DEFRA but this action is so pig-headed (which isn’t being very fair to pigs) that I can barely believe it. Not to be at the meeting when there has been such a public outcry of support for the beavers is appalling. So sadly disappointed.

Sherry

Beyond awful… these bureaucracies (including most in the U.S.) are so entrenched in old lies and myths and habits… so sorry to hear the latest example.

Thanks Derek, I have written to Hugo Swire MP at the request of a local resident, to ask him to liaise with DEFRA officials to invite them to a public meeting in Ottery St Mary to explain their plans.

I am happy to organise it. So far no response from Mr Swire, but we are not giving up.

Cllr Claire Wright
http://www.claire-wright.org

David Gibbon

It is interesting to read the Defra paper on EM and the risk of it coming in through beavers. Clearly it is a miniscule risk and one that could be assessed without this heavy handed approach. I think this along with the badger cull, could be enough to lose the Tories the next election.

Comments are closed for this post !!

DONATE

BAY AREA PODCAST

Our story told around the county

Beaver Interactive: Click to view

LASSIE INVENTS BDA

URBAN BEAVERS

LASSIE AND BEAVERS

Ten Years

The Beaver Cheat Sheet

Restoration

RANGER RICK

Ranger rick

The meeting that started it all

Past Reports

September 2024
M T W T F S S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30  

Story By Year

close

Share the beaver gospel!